Welcome to Bailey's Smokehouse - New City
Welcome to Bailey's Smokehouse - New City, a hidden gem nestled on S Main St, where rustic charm meets mouthwatering barbecue. Our story is rooted in a passion for slow-smoked flavors and generous portions. We take pride in crafting delicious dishes like our famous Slow-Roasted Ribs and Bailey’s Loaded Fries, all served with a side of warm hospitality. The inviting atmosphere is perfect for sharing memorable meals with friends and family, while our strong, refreshing drinks promise to enhance your visit. Join us for an unforgettable culinary experience that celebrates the art of smoke and the joy of community.
-
191 S Main St, New City, NY 10956 Hotline: (845) 875-7692
Welcome to Bailey's Smokehouse - New City, an inviting smokehouse and pub located at 191 S Main St, New City, NY 10956. As you step inside, you’ll be greeted by a rustic charm that belies its modest exterior. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it an ideal spot for families, friends, or casual gatherings.
At Bailey's, the food truly shines. This establishment is renowned for its mouthwatering BBQ offerings. Local reviews highlight dishes like the pulled short rib sandwich and the impressive sampler platter, which provides an abundance of flavors. The BBQ Skins, topped with cheddar jack cheese and your choice of smoked meats, is a perfect appetizer choice, while the Texas Lollipops—smoked sausage wrapped in bacon—are simply irresistible.
For those who love sharing, the Bailey's Loaded Fries and Mac N' Cheese Egg Rolls are crowd-pleasers. The latter has received numerous accolades for its creamy filling and tantalizing flavor—it’s a dish you won't soon forget. If you’re a fan of variety, don’t miss the Table Buster, a hearty feast featuring pulled pork, pulled chicken, brisket, sausage, and ribs—all generously served with three sides!
A few customers noted the service could be a bit slow at times, but the friendly staff makes up for it with their attentiveness. Plus, with strong drinks to accompany your meal, the experience is bound to be enjoyable. The beverage selection is praised as well, with some claiming Bailey's serves the best Coca Cola they've ever had.
While the food generally garners rave reviews, it’s worth noting that not every dish will be universally loved. There have been comments about occasional inconsistencies in side dishes, like overly salty vegetables. However, the staff is responsive to feedback and works diligently to ensure customer satisfaction.
In conclusion, Bailey's Smokehouse - New City stands out as a remarkable spot for BBQ lovers and anyone seeking a hearty meal. The aroma of smoked meats wafts through the air, promising an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this smokehouse is definitely worth a visit.
-First Impression- Looks small, like there wouldn't be enough space to sit, but when you walk in you're really only seeing half of the space. -Food- absolutely delicious! I think about that short rib sandwich from time to time and salivate. The sides and dessert were also very good -Service- A bit slow, took a very long time to get more water, and I was thirsty :( -Price- portions are generous so you get a lot of food for your money -Did Not Like- see service -Noteworthy- the drinks are STRONG! -Recommended?- yes
Best BBQ around, I love coming here. My girlfriend and I split the sampler platter appetizer and that was a good amount for dinner. Also their Coca Cola is the best I've ever had. 10/10 recommend!
Great food. Use them for all the time for our fundraisers. We say Bailey's is catering and everyone wants to buy a ticket
Ribs and chicken were great. Sides were awful. Chicken was tender and juicy. Ribs were cooked perfectly.
First time to Bailey's and we'll definitely be back. My family and I split The Table Buster- pulled pork, pulled chicken, brisket, sausage and ribs with seasoned fries and 3 large sides! So much food wow! The pulled pork was 10/10! The sausage was a little on the spicy side. For the sides, we got baked beans, corn soufflé and roasted broccoli. The roasted broccoli was extremely hard and salty. We notified our waitress and she quickly switched it out for another side at no additional charge. The staff were extremely friendly. There is a large bar, but also many tables. The music was a little on the hard to hear what my table was saying but they adjusted it as the meal went on without us saying anything. We had leftovers for days!
Was visiting from out of town and was recommended to try this by a friend. All of the food choices sounded delicious! From nachos, to steak, to sandwiches! I ended up getting a pulled short rib sandwich. It was very tasty but the sauce felt like it was missing something (not too sweet and not to spicy kinda just there). The seasoned fries and the side choices were amazing. For an appetizer we split the Mac and Cheese egg rolls! Mmm chef kiss. My partner got the smokehouse stacked bbq burger. He said it was good but really loaded with toppings so be prepared to press/smush it down. The chips that came with his were nice and crunchy. Grilled chicken wrap with Cesar salad inside was good. The salad was very creamy and substantial. The short rib grilled cheese was also eaten at our table and was very substantial. The portion was nice and hot upon arrival to the table and the pressed sandwich was nice. We went at about 11:40 on a Thursday and it was fairly quiet. Really appreciated the service and the friendliness of the staff!